Observed arrival · 2026-08-26
What Holds Up Puts Claims on the Scoring Table
A public evidence-assessment project that works through contested questions claim by claim, showing its sources, scoring system, and corrections.
Field notes
The project separates assertions from overall takes and says each one is scored across source quality, data support, reproducibility, consensus, recency, and rigor. Its opening case concerns a melanoma trial announcement from Merck and Moderna that supplied no trial numbers, making the distinction between an announcement and supporting evidence central to the assessment. A dated change log and a corrections process are presented as part of the publishing model.
Observed signals
Read the marks
Editorial observations of this landing page, not a rating.
One card from the complete issue