First Referee, for meeting Reviewer 2 before submission

Field notes

The proposed report is organized into six practical sections, including a likely editorial verdict, ranked fatal problems, expected reviewer attacks, missing recent citations, and a suggested submission destination. Reviewer eligibility is defined as authorship of at least three papers in the relevant subfield since 2024, with identity verification through ORCID and conflict screening. The site also says file access is logged and that manuscripts are excluded from model training, while advisory-board appointments remain pending.