Observed arrival · 2026-10-09

Baseball GOAT: who was actually better?

baseballgoat.app Visit website

Editorial interest 82/100 Selection signal · not a rating of the site

An interactive set of all-time baseball rankings, with era-adjusted player scores, team and position lineups, and head-to-head comparisons.

Landing page captured for the 2026-10-09 issue.

For: Baseball fans comparing players across eras
Worth noticing: The site says its numbers exclude fielding skill and postseason play, a caveat that leaves room for plenty of ranking disputes.

Field notes

The methodology describes a wins-added measure, adjusted against the league in each player's season, with career value blended with the best seven seasons. The page says hitting, baserunning, position, and pitching count, and that short schedules receive credit toward a full season. It also flags two omissions—fielding skill and postseason play—so the displayed rankings are not presented as a measure of every part of a player's value.

Observed signals

Read the marks

Editorial observations of this landing page, not a rating.

○OpenPublic substance visible

✦PrettyNotable craft visible

●ProPolished or operationally mature

◎NicheUnusually specific use

ƒJavaScriptBrowser-side code central

One card from the complete issue

Are You Scared?

420,208 arrived 1,000 judged 984 catalogued Enter the complete issue