Observed arrival · 2026-11-20
Propane Refill Guide’s Refill-vs-Exchange Math
A sourced directory of propane refill locations with city guides and comparisons of refilling a cylinder you own versus exchanging it.
- For
- Propane users comparing tank refills with exchanges
- Worth noticing
- For Charlotte, it declines to invent an exchange price and models refill costs from U-Haul’s posted $4.15–$4.95-per-gallon range.
Field notes
For Charlotte, the guide converts Tractor Supply’s approximate 4.6-gallon capacity for a typical 20-pound cylinder into refill-cost examples using U-Haul location-page rates of $4.15 and $4.95 per gallon, plus tax. It compares a roughly 15-pound exchange fill with a cylinder filled toward 20 pounds, while noting that leftover propane in an exchanged tank earns no credit. Sources include NIST, Blue Rhino, Tractor Supply, U-Haul, and PHMSA; the listed figures were checked November 18, 2026, and may change.
Observed signals
Read the marks
Editorial observations of this landing page, not a rating.
One card from the complete issue